CANADIAN ERROR COINS - DIE VARIETIES

The Creation of Canadian Dies

A suitable design is chosen.

 The design of a die usually begins as a concept or a theme.  Before the design is chosen, a suitable sketch may be obtained in several ways.  The most direct way is to generate the sketch "in house."  This was done, for example, in the case of the 1977 Queen's Silver Jubilee silver dollar when Royal Canadian Mint engraver Walter Ott made an ink drawing of the throne of the senate.  On other occasions, such as the 1937 coinage, a select group of outside artists were invited to submit designs.  The modern method is to have open competitions that any Canadian can enter.  The designs for the 1951 commemorative 5 cent piece and the 1964 silver dollar were the results of open competitions, along with the “CANADA 125 coinage.”  More recently the “Millennium” coinage and many of the commemorative Two dollar coins, were also the result of open competitions.  To date, this has been the method most frequently used by the Royal Canadian Mint.   

Once a suitable sketch is obtained,
the engraver models the design
in modeling clay. 

Once a suitable sketch is obtained, the engraver models the design in modeling clay.  This model is made on a large scale, usually 9 to 10 inches in diameter.  The model is then cast in plaster of paris in intaglio (incused), from which a cameo (raised) is cast.  During these steps, improvements and finishing touches are added, such as the lettering, improvements to finer details, and facial details.  The final cast is in acrylic plastic. 

Pantograph machine reduces the design.

This is placed on a three dimensional pantograph machine which reduces the design and reproduces it in steel, in two cuts.  The first being a rough cut followed by a second cut, both cuts require a day each to complete.  Depending on the size of the model and die, a brass intermediate reproduction may be required.  The final reproduction is called the “Reduction punch” or the “Master hub”.  From the master hub at least two “Matrix or Master dies” are made by placing it in a powerful press and impressing its design into soft steel blocks, which are later hardened.  For small mintage coinage such as a one year or monthly commemorative, the need for a master hub is bypassed by using a reversed image (incused) model on the pantograph machine. 

 The end result is incused.  After the denticles or beads are added and other finishing touches applied, the steel block is hardened to become a master die. 

Finishing touches being applied.

From the master die one or more “Working punches or Hubs” are produced in the same manner as the master die was made.  “Working dies” are then produced in the same manner.  A single working hub can produce thousands of dies before it is retired.  Currently full design transfer between a hub and die, known as hubbing, can be achieved in one strike with the use of a restraining collar around the die blank while imparting its design.   

Prior to 1980 Smaller dies such as one and ton cents required at least two separate impressions before acceptable design transfer was achieved, larger denominations took up to five hubbings.  Slight varying misalignments between hubbings have resulted many types of “Doubled Dies” as known to exist by hobbyists.   

In Victorian times prior to the use of a pantograph machine (1900) master dies were produced by hand and with the use of “Hobs”- e.g.- a punch bearing the portrait of Queen Victoria or other major devices were used in conjunction with number and letter punches to produce the master die.  Working hubs and dies were produced by the current method.  It is also important to note that it was a common practice by the Royal Mint in that era to “rehub” worn dies.  Sometimes worn dies were used to produce smaller size denominations.  Occasionally a master die has been totally hand engraved as was done in 1949 with the one dollar commemorative by Royal Canadian Mints, at that time chief engraver, Thomas Shingles.  

Dies being prepared for plating.

Press used to produce working Dies, about 1910.

Prior to 1908 Canadian coins were struck with both major die axis arrangements.  In the medal arrangement (designated áá) a coin held vertically between one's fingers with its obverse design right side up finishes with its reverse design right up when it is rotated on its vertical axis.  Dies in coinage arrangement (áâ) will result in the reverse being upside down when the coin is turned as previously described.  All Canadian coins struck by the Royal Canadian Mint (1908) have been in the medal arrangement (áá).   

The collar (the piece of metal that restrains the sideways expansion of the blank during striking, thus forcing metal to flow into all incused design elements, and gives the coin its shape and edge design) is made at the Ottawa mint.  For plain edge coins a hole is simply drilled in the centre of an appropriate piece of steel.  If the collar is to be for a reeded edge coin, a smooth edge hole is drilled.  Then the hole is given a serrated edge by the use of a small, hardened steel wheel.  

More Die production images

MASTER HUB -design is raised
is struck to create a -

 MASTER DIE - design is incused
is struck to create a -

 HUB - design is raised
is struck to create a -

 DIE - design is incused
is struck to create a -

 COIN - design is raised.

Major Die Variety Minor Die Variety
Die alterations made either intentionally
or unintentionally prior to use.
Die alterations due to die use and wear.
Most are progressive in nature.
Punch Spacing Die Chip
Different Punch Style Die Crack
Repunched Retained Broken Die
Over Punched Broken Die (Cuds)
Added Punch Collar Crack
Damaged Hub Pitted Die
Modified Design Peeled Chrome Plating
Mismatched Die (Mules) Die Deterioration Doubling
Misaligned Die Resurfaced Die
Rotated Die Die Clash
Doubled Die Tool Damage
Collar Type Die Shift
The use of the terms of major and minor by these definitions apply only to Canadian die varieties.

The Evolution of Minor Die Varieties

Eventually, after a period of use, coinage dies do breakdown, in some cases earlier than others.  Poor Quality steel from which dies are formed, was clearly a problem in die production (particularly during the Victorian era).  The breaking down of a die may at first reveal;

 “Die Chips” small chipped of portions of the die, usually where the field meets an element.  Also weaknesses in the design of the die, in regards to metal flow, account for many chipped dies such as plugged dates and letters.

 “Die Cracks” that are progressive in nature will occur.  Coins struck by cracked dies will mirror the crack showing as a raised line on the coin, usually in the fields extending from design elements.

 “Die Breaks” Are the result dies continuing to strike coins, the die crack tends to grow longer and deeper into the die, eventually this will result in a piece of the die breaking off.  Coins struck by dies with broken off edges are known as “Die Breaks” (more popularly known as in the USA as “Cuds”).

 “Pitted Dies” Dies formed by poor steel may result in porosity being exposed in the field after polishing, these pits may appear as dots when impressed to form a coin.  Tool damage and other types die mishandling may also result in producing 'dots.' 

Chipped or Peeled Plating” occurred quite commonly.  Beginning in 1941 the mint began chrome plating the dies to prolong die life.  In the early years (1941-1965) of plating dies many problems arouse, due to difficulties in the adhering of the plating.

 “Die Deterioration Doubling” usually appears late in die life (unless it was helped by polishing) and is caused by fatigue around recessed design elements on the die.  This doubling usually extends on all sides of the raised element, often accompanied by fields exhibiting 'orange peel effect' typical of worn dies.  Often both of the die pair are affected.  Polishing dies to remove clash marks (e.g.) can also produce this effect and may appear on fresh looking dies.

 “Over-Surfaced Die” during some years, used dies and damage (e.g. clash marks) were totally resurfaced and replated.  Fine details are sometimes removed and elements may appear smaller.

 "Die Clash"  marks on coins are the result of working dies striking each other when no planchet is between them. Bent planchets when fed into a hopper- feeder will jam, preventing planchets from being placed in coining chamber.  The face of most modern dies is slightly convex. On these issues, die clashes are deepest at their highest points, nearest to the centre of the coin.  On dies that are concave, clash marks will be found nearer to the edge of the coin. Due to modifications of the presses in 1980, that enable presses to disengage dies if no planchet is fed, these varieties are seldom seen anymore.

 "Die Shift" may be caused by a loose die, this is actually damage that occurs after the strike and damage that occurs after the strike may be duplicated.  The doubling is the result of displacement (shearing) of the raised element, this pushing over the metal not only narrows the elements, but also pushes this metal up on the edge of each character.  When the base of the doubling is added to raised part, it is equal to the full normal size of the raised element. On regular coinage, meant for circulation, this is rather common and does not justify a premium value as a minting variety.  

 Doubled Dies

 Currently eight classes of hub doubling are recognized.

Class I-"Rotated Hub Doubling"-results from a rotation (in either direction) of the second impression in relation to the first.

Class II - “Distorted Hub Doubling”-occurs when the hub has spread out or distorted between impressions, and may involve the use of two different hubs.

Class III - “Design Hub Doubling” -always involves two different hubs, one with a different design, or the design in a different location.

Class IV - “Offset Hub Doubling” -occurs when the second impression is offset in any direction.

Class V - “Pivoted Hub Doubling” -occurs when the second impression is pivoted at some point, usually the rim, so that the doubling increases in a fan shape from the pivot point.

Class VI - “Distended Hub Doubling” -often will not show he distinct notching that all other forms of hub doubling, as it results in a thickening of elements and design.

Class VII - “Modified Hub Doubling” -results from the use of a modified hub.

Class VIII - “Partial Hub Doubling”-occurs when a die is partially hubbed, usually offset, and is rehubbed.  

There are also - T. D. -Tripled Dies and Q. D. - Quadrupled Dies.  
O - denotes obverse die, R - reverse die.  
Doubled Die are listed in this order:  
Denotes which Die the class-  
for example - $1.00 1947 Pointed Seven 1-R-V & T.D.0-II  
1 means it is the first recorded for that date, Tripled die Obverse .

 

  Die Axis Arrangement

Dies in the coinage alignment (áâ)

Newfoundland  
-1872 (only) One cent.  
-Five cents.  
-Ten cents.  
-Twenty cents.  
-Fifty cents.  

New Brunswick  
-Five cents.  

Province of Canada  
-Five cents.  
-Ten cents.  
-Twenty cents.  

Canada  
-Five Cents 1870-1907.  
-Ten Cents 1870-1907.  
-Twenty-Five Cents 1870-1907.  
-Fifty Cents 1870-1907.

Dies in the medal alignment (áá)

New Brunswick and Nova Scotia Half Cent and One Cent.  
Prince Edward Island One Cent.  
Newfoundland One Cent except 1872.  
Province of Canada One Cent.
All Canadian One cent, and beginning 1908 (Since the Royal Canadian Mint began to strike coins) all coinage.

 

Concave, Convex and Flat Dies

Since 1858, all coinage for Canada has been struck from dies of different curvatures. Dies may also vary in slight degrees in their curvature. It can vary yearly or within the denominations depending on the design.

 

Minting Variety Directory | Canadian Error Coin Directory | Main Directory

Page created by: muckwa
Changes last made on: 02/14/10


The entire contents of the Canadian Error Coins website are ©Copyright 1997-2010. Permission is granted to non-profit organizations and to individuals for their personal use, to copy any of the material contained herein, on the condition that such copies are not to be sold or otherwise used for profit, and that Patrick Glassford is shown as the source of such information or material.
The Canadian Error Coins website (est. in 1997 by Patrick Glassford) is a division of the Canadian Numismatic Publishing Institute, established in 1958 by Somer James, publisher of many fine Canadian numismatic publications such as "A GUIDE BOOK OF CANADIAN COINS, CURRENCY & TOKENS" and "CANADIAN SILVER DOLLARS" by Starr Gilmore.

The Canadian Numismatic Publishing Institute (CNPI), and all its existing copyrights,
are the sole property of Patrick Glassford.